The fact of the matter is, I overthought it. I overthought it, and then I oversold it. I trembled across the slim line between cop cars. On the highway, legs wet on the leather, I hit the gas. Unclothed, I dove into the shaft of freezing water and had to be pulled back up. Every second available to me, a pearl gasping in my hands. Every word available to me, a bomb about to go off.
Cliché of clichés. Red felt cloche in my baby photo. Chained to a man’s broken hip, I blow off work to lay on the two-seater and write a script of how to apologize to you. But though I know what I want to say, I can’t decide why I want to say it. Do I want to be vulnerable, or do I want to attempt vulnerability to force tender feelings in you? Come on, cries out the chorus, we know the answer. You can’t even listen to music without pretending you’re singing to an audience. So white-robed, white-socked, sleep-deprived, I stand at the metal table and pour out nectar, bleach, milk, vinegar, in different configurations. I attempt pools of craven magic, because what I want is not to be honest but to to generate a specific feeling in you. A magician’s assistant, or a control freak?
Underneath the eaves, you comment on the rain. On the evening train, you mention your dream. Off-hand, my spleen flung off-ramp. Is this a show of honesty intended to enchant me? If so, you’ve succeeded. You’ve conquered the cynic. You brewed a potion in a teaspoon and felled me for a lifetime. It’s hard to be so easily claimed when I know that you were not even trying, and that’s the way you won me. You’re like this with everyone and I resent it. I resent so powerfully the quality of yours that I most respect. It means I’m not special but come on, cries out the crowd: If you had been, you would have rejected him. Paradox of paradoxes. If there is a God, deliver unto me a box of white peaches, clefts ready for the sword. If there is God, deliver unto me a crate of wine bottles, so I can uncork them and refuse to drink.
Of course, I fool myself when I call myself a cynic. It’s no mystery. When Seneca said, life is long if you know how to use it, I cried. It’s not possible to overestimate the limits of my sentimentality, made all the more grotesque by sardonic indifference, which is somehow, in me, its conjoined twin. You don’t know catastrophizing until you’ve seen me do it on stage. Putting my blood-streaked hand into the black top hat and under the blinding spotlight, retrieving the pink cliché, the slippery paradox. I’m a romantic who wants nothing more than not to be loved.
The problem is, in my spoken parts, drafted on stolen laundry and overdue library books, written with sweat from syringes and blood that can’t congeal, I don’t say what I mean—only what I think you want to hear. No, not even that. The truth is, I write for myself that which I want to hear myself saying. I want to be the kind of person who’d say these things out loud. Can I dare to hope that this means that I do mean them? But it can’t be true because if you flinched, I’d take it all back in an instant. That’s how deep my pretensions go. That’s how fake I am. How fatal it is to perform because if you drew back at the intensity of a performance that went a little too far, that fell off the line, that forgot the brakes, that couldn’t come up for breath, I wouldn’t be able to talk myself out of it. Now that’s what I call an unforced error.